Crypto · 9-year review

BTC vs. ETH: which crypto actually won since Ethereum began trading?

Two of the largest cryptocurrencies, one $10,000 starting line. Here is how they actually compared since Ethereum’s first day of trading.

$10,000 invested in BTC on November 9, 2017 — the first day Ethereum has price data on this site — would have grown to $108,032 by September 11, 2026, a 980.3% return. The same $10,000 in ETH over the identical period would have grown to $76,418, a 664.2% return — a real gain, but well behind Bitcoin’s.

	Starting price	Ending price	Return
BTC	$7,143.58	$77,173.80	+980.3%
ETH	$320.88	$2,452.12	+664.2%

Why BTC pulled ahead

Bitcoin has consistently held the largest share of the total crypto market over this period, and tends to draw the bulk of institutional and “store of value” interest specifically — capital that treats it more like digital gold than a speculative bet. Ethereum, by contrast, functions more like a platform: its price reflects not just demand for ETH itself, but the broader health of the applications, NFTs, and decentralized finance activity built on top of it, which has been a choppier, more cyclical source of demand over this stretch.

Ethereum also underwent a fundamental change to how new coins are created partway through this period, shifting away from the energy-intensive mining process Bitcoin still uses. That shift was widely seen as a long-term positive for the network, but it did not translate into ETH out-earning BTC over this particular window.

Both are far more volatile than a typical stock or ETF

The 980% and 664% figures above are real, but they hide a genuinely bumpy ride to get there. Both BTC and ETH have had stretches of 50% or larger drawdowns within this same period — something almost never seen in a broad stock market index fund. A near-9-year total return is not the same as a smooth, steady climb for either asset.

Past performance is not a preview

Nearly nine years of BTC beating ETH does not mean the next nine will look the same — the two assets serve genuinely different purposes, and which one leads has shifted before over shorter stretches within this same period. The honest takeaway is not “Bitcoin is better” — it is that the two carry different kinds of risk, and this particular window rewarded the more established, less application-dependent one.

Try your own comparison

Pick any two tickers and any timeframe to see how they actually compare, using the same real closing-price data behind the numbers above.

Compare any two assets →

Or just run the numbers on one asset alone.

Figures shown reflect historical closing-price performance only and exclude staking rewards, trading fees, and taxes. Cryptocurrency prices are highly volatile and speculative. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This article is for educational purposes only and is not personalized financial or investment advice.